What Do Conservatives Really Want?
June 27, 2010
Jackson Sun Op-Ed by T. Robert Hill
For decades the Republican mantra has been “smaller government” and “tax cuts” for the wealthy but is this what they really want or just a “sound bite” to maintain the status quo?
If we examine our history, we find that smaller government meant child labor, no compensation for on-the-job injuries, no overtime pay, no health insurance and no pensions. It also meant no public transportation, no public roads, no public schools, no government supported police or fire departments and no government supported hospitals. Giant private utilities controlled power and water resources. Most industries were monopolized by single individuals and families like the Rockefellers, Carnegies and Fords. This was the picture in the early 1900’s leading up to The Great Depression.
Today we have child labor laws, worker’s compensation, a 40-hour work week with overtime pay, access to health care through public health departments, Medicare and Social Security. We also have city buses, public roads, police and fire protection provided by taxpayer funds and hospitals like ourJackson Madison County General Hospital. We also have the National Guard, Army, Navy, Air Force, Marines, and Coast Guard. Which government service would the American people be willing to give up?
Today, the Republicans’ “small government” means a lack of industry regulation on oil companies, coal mining, banks and big business. Recent Republican administrations have been successful in keeping these area of government extremely small and inefficient over the last thirty (30) years.
Oil industry regulations were wiped out during the Bush-Cheney years. One need simply recall the Bush-Cheney closed-door White House meetings with oil executives to “set” our national oil agenda to see the cause and effect. Now we have oil companies who cut corners and ignore safety issues to increase profits. No doubt it seemed like a great plan at the time. Then an offshore rig essentially exploded, killing 11 Americans and causing unimaginable damage to the Gulf Coast region. Suddenly, instead of “drill, baby, drill” Republican governors from Alabama, Florida, Mississippi and Louisiana are all crying for federal government intervention and resources. Where will those resources come from? Why taxpayer dollars, of course. In addition, all those Republicans who scream for caps on liability in cases of malpractice are now screaming to take the liability caps off BP. Of course, there are a few, like Sen. David Vitter (R-La.) who feel “sorry” for BP, that’s British Petroleum, and believe the federal government alone should protect and clean up the Gulf Coast.
Mining regulations were also rolled back during the Bush-Cheney years. As a result, mining companies appeal time after time, regardless of the number of safety violations found. Meanwhile, the companies are never required to fix the problem during the appeal process. Then we have a horrific explosion resulting in 24 deaths of American fathers, sons and brothers.
Banking and investment regulations were trashed during the Republican reign. As a result, millions of homes went into foreclosure as risky loans were approved, bundled and sold by the giant Wall Street investment firms.
Big businesses became increasingly deregulated during past Republican administrations, including eight (8) years of Bush-Cheney. As a result, American companies have moved more and more business to third world countries, utilizing what is essentially slave labor to increase their bottom line while devastating small-town America in the process. But Republicans want more and more for the corporate profiteers and less and less for everyday Americans.
Here’s the rub.
The Republican Party, and its’ recently spawned Tea baggers, want government to stay out of corporate life, but they want more and more government regulation for certain individuals’ personal lives. They want freedom and liberty for corporate America, but want the government to prohibit things they don’t believe in, like abortion and gay marriage. So do they really want small government, or do they just want government that supports their “right wing” issues and pads their corporate buddies pocketbooks? Truly, a giant conservative hypocrisy is the best way to describe these present Republican “sound bites.”
The American people, particularly those here in Jackson, have a choice to make in upcoming elections. Do you really want smaller government with fewer regulations and less oversight, or do you want a balanced, responsive and responsible government that provides essential services with reasonable taxes?